Spain

Last Race: 12th May Spain

Spain GP Results
Pos Driver
1 Fernando Alonso
2 Kimi Raikkonen
3 Felipe Massa

Neale responds to criticism

Saturday 9th June 2012

 RSS
Neale responds to criticism

Neale responds to criticism

McLaren managing director Jonathan Neale has defended his team against BBC technical analyst Gary Anderson's criticism.

Anderson, who worked as technical director with Jordan and Stewart Grand Prix from 1991 to 2003, was less than complimentary regarding a gearbox issue with Jensen Button's car that effectively wrecked his practice session ahead of Sunday's Canadian Grand Prix.

The British driver was forced to spend most of the second session watching from the sidelines.

"This is a top team with a world champion challenging for the world championship," said Anderson.

"They're changing the gearbox - it should be 30 minutes. It's not good enough.

"During that time Caterham rebuilt the car of Heikki Kovalainen, who hit the wall.

"McLaren discovered they hadn't fixed an oil leak, and they had to change the gearbox, but that should be a half-hour job.

"If you're trying to win the championship, you can't afford to make mistakes like this."

Neale explained what happened however, hinting that Anderson appears to be out of touch with a modern-day F1 car.

"You have to go back to FP1," he said.

"As Jenson came out of the last corner on his final run he felt he had a lot of wheel spin, which turned out to be clutch slip.

"After getting the car into the garage and taking it apart we found oil contamination of the clutch which causes the plates to slip. Clearly it was something we had to address.

"The oil was coming from the gearbox through one of the seals, which we would routinely change.

"But the problem these days, if you take a modern gearbox on a Formula One car, they, and the powertrain in particular, are so integrated now.

"The packaging is so extreme that to take off a gearbox and put it on again routinely takes, on average up and down the grid, an hour and three quarters.

"Bear in mind to even start a Formula One car from a laptop from cold these days takes an hour and a half.

"So it's not as trivial as some might have you believe.

"So we changed the seal in between FP1 and FP2, got the car back together, got the floor on, fired it up and discovered we then had a secondary issue which wasn't knowable prior to that event.

"So it all had to come off again and we had to do two gearbox changes.

"There wasn't time to delve into the root cause, so we changed the back end of the car, which was another hour and three quarters.

"We apologise to Jenson for the unreliability, but we're back on it and I'm confident we've a good car, as Lewis Hamilton has attested and we'll be back on it tomorrow."

Button eventually finished half a second down on Hamilton, who was quickest throughout the two sessions, with a best lap-time of 1:15.259.

User comments

    Loading

      Post a comment

      Gallery: Race Day At Barcelona

      Editor's Picks

      Winner and Losers: Spain

      Winner and Losers: Spain

      Alonso reigned in Spain, while the rest of the grid had to ask their engineers how fast they were allowed to drive...

      The PF1 Fantasy League

      The PF1 Fantasy League

      Join the PlanetF1 Fantasy League and go up against the crew at PF1 in our 2013 Friends and Enemies battle...

      The Benetton Class Of 2001

      The Benetton Class Of 2001

      There's something special about the four Benetton drivers lining up in St Mark's Square - they're all in the 200 Club...

      Spain With Lotus & Sure

      Spain With Lotus & Sure

      Lotus sponsor Sure For Men brings you a detailed account of the team's Spanish weekend - from the sublime to the absurd...

      The Forum Is Ready To Chat

      The Forum Is Ready To Chat

      Ferrari came apart (literally), Vettel became the first to two, Lotus put two into the top three and the protests continued. Let's chat...